Wednesday, September 23, 2026

What is Algebra?

It’s fun to see how algebra was done before the so called “symbolic” algebra.

I’d argue that all algebra is symbolic, because language is symbolic. Rhetorical algebra just uses word symbols. Numbers and variables and operations and concepts all use alphanumeric symbols in symbolic algebra, but it’s not like “ush”, “sag”, “lagab”, and “sukud” aren’t symbols themselves. They are symbols, and they do pack some meaning and concepts and understandings in them.

But given what I saw from Mesopotamian scribes, they did have algebra. They just used words (which are themselves symbols) that are longer than single alphanumeric characters. They also had the concept of multiplication, but it relied on specific concepts for two-value multiplication (area) and three-value multiplication (volume). I’m not sure if they had the concept of four-value multiplication, because it does not directly translate to something in our three-dimensional world. Even if somewhat incomplete compared to modern algebra, this is algebra.

I was always encouraged by my mother o try my best to explain my thought process and my ideas when solving math. So for me, for most of my primary and early secondary school, my answers to math problems were more like a short answer than a sequence of math expressions. When you explain your thoughts you can find some missing parts, and it makes it easier for the person reading to see what you meant.

When getting into more abstract and complex math it starts getting harder and impractical to write everything to it’s most basic and tangible concepts. Symbolic algebra does make things more compact, and abstractions help handle general operations between complex concepts. For example, how many books would be needed to translate Euler’s Identity from its few characters to tangible and mundane concepts? And when dealing with imaginary numbers, the abstraction of treating it just as an element lets you perform operations on it without the constant reminder of what it is. Eventually you may use the property that it multiplied by itself is negative one, but other than that it behaves mostly normally.

Bottom line is: they did have algebra. The abstraction and shortening of the concepts into single alphanumeric characters help us save ink and time to write, and also helps lower the cognitive load needed to perform computations, but that’s not what algebra is all about. Maybe if we had infinite cognitive capacity and could write infinitely fast with an infinite source of clay tablets, maybe the lack of need to shorten and abstract algebra would have never driven us to “symbolic” algebra and we could still be using cuneiform Babylonian math.

1 comment:

  1. Fascinating discussion, Francisco! I think you're getting at a really important distinction between the compactness and "thing-ness" or object-making nature of the very brief alphanumeric symbols we use for algebra, and their dissociation from physical models like area and volume. Those two features give the algebra we're used to an additional power of abstraction compared to so-called rhetorical and geometric algebra. You might be interested in reading Anna Sfard's article about this:

    Sfard, A. (2012). Symbolizing mathematical reality into being—or how mathematical discourse and mathematical objects create each other. In Symbolizing and communicating in mathematics classrooms (pp. 37-98). Routledge.

    ReplyDelete